I found myself troubled on the way home from seeing The Simpsons Movie last night. For one thing, I really, really enjoyed it. But on the other hand it left a slightly sour taste in my mouth.
I should probably elaborate, so I’ll start from the beginning.
The film is funny. It goes without saying that the film is by far the funniest thing that the Simpsons production team have put out in the past few years. The jokes seldom miss their mark; the animation, while a little patchy in places, is generally much better quality than the televised episodes (which is to be expected really); and the voice-acting is top-notch. The actors have really improved their game for the movie, with the most noticeable improvement perhaps being Julie Kavner, who voices Marge. Marge has become somewhat of a stale character over the years, and her voice has become rather predictable. But the story in the film, contrived as it was, allowed Kavner to pour some actual emotion and heart into her performance. It was fantastic.
The story, however, is a bit contrived. Of course it’s contrived. The Simpsons has had great difficulty coming up with original, fun-to-watch stories since the turn of the century, and the movie is an example of this. However The Simpsons is not the only series-turned-movie to suffer from this problem. On the way home my mind turned to thoughts of The Rugrats Movie, which suffered a similar problem. The story, big in scale as it is, didn’t quite work for me as a whole.
But the story is, in my view, a vehicle. It’s a vehicle for some of the funniest jokes that the Simpsons has made in a long time, and some of the biggest laughs I’ve had in a theatre for a while. The last time I laughed this hard at a film with this many people was probably Hot Fuzz, and although the laughs here weren’t quite as loud, they were perhaps more regular. Not to say that The Simpsons Movie is better than Hot Fuzz, which has an actual story to accompany its jokes. But the experience in the theater was much the same - a lot of people laughing hard at something funny. I guess that makes The Simpsons Movie an amalgamation of the shows’ past and present - the fantastic humour of the Golden Age of the show mixed with the poor storylines of the current seasons.
Is The Simpsons Movie a cinematic classic? No. Is it going to be successful? Yes. Is that success justified? Honestly, yes it is. The film very nearly makes up for the lack of quality in the television series over the past few years. Perhaps the quality dipped because they were working on the film. Who can say? But the film is worth seeing, preferably in a theater full of people, and it’s probably worth getting on DVD too, if not for the film then for the special features (the film had an “interesting” development history which I am eager to see).
If I had to score it out of ten, I’d probably give it a 7.5. Maybe an 8.
Tags: